With their embarrassing 8-3 loss last night to Atlanta, I have officially given up on the Mets season. Not that I had much hope to begin with, but I felt if they could go 6-0/5-1 on this road trip they would at least get themselves back in it. Of course, that was a long shot to happen anyway and last night officially ended that idea, along with my hopes for 2010.
The Mets now sit 7.5 games behind Atlanta for first place. It certainly isn’t impossible to come back from such a deficit, as the Mets themsevles showed us just a few years ago in only 17 games. However, add in the fact that the Mets not only have to worry about the Braves, but the Phillies and Marlins as well, and it shows you just how difficult it is going to be for them. Even if the Mets sweep the Phillies this weekend, they’d still be 2.5 games behind them. And the Phillies haven’t even had their A-team out there all season.
**Side note — The injuries the Phillies have faced this season (Rollins, Victorino, Utley, Howard, Polanco, Ruiz, and more) are very comparable to what the happened to the Mets last year. Yet, while the 2009 Mets scuffled and used their injuries as an excuse, the Phillies keep winning and get Roy Oswalt to boot. But that’s another story for another day.**
As for the Wild Card? Being 8 games back of San Francisco, the Mets are actually closer to the division lead. And let’s just say, for arguments sake, the Mets actually catch up to Philadelphia and take over second in the NL East. That still only puts them in third place for the Wild Card, with the Giants and St. Louis/Cincinnati ahead of them.
So now that I have become the ultimate Debbie Downer, I might as well take it a step further and say now is the perfect time to fire Jerry Manuel. You have an off-day and you just lost a series that you needed to win in order to keep your season alive. The team went the entire month of July without winning consecutive games, a streak that actually dates back to June 24, and they’ve won only two road series all year. You might as well cut the cord and start looking ahead to 2011.
Before I continue, let’s get this out of the way — is this season entirely Jerry’s fault? No. Did baseball experts say before the season the Mets were no better than a .500 team? Yes. However, did baseball experts also say if the Mets were in fact no better than a .500 team it would not bode well for Jerry and Omar? Yes they did.
Jerry Manuel seems like a great guy and I’m sure he is. Unfortunately, he is not in the nice guy business, he is in the winning business and has not won. The main problem I have with Jerry is his lack of a plan, which I think is a problem with the Mets as a whole. Many times Jerry will tell us he’s going to do something then doesn’t do it. This series with Atlanta is a prime example of that. He talked about his disappointment in Luis Castillo and the bottom of the order and said changes needed to be made, then the next night he runs out the exact same lineup (which includes Castillo), only replacing Henry Blanco with Josh Thole…wow, what a dramatic shake-up… Then we take a look at last night. Mike Pelfrey is scuffling in the 5th and SNY shows us left-hander Hisanori Takahashi warming up in the bullpen. Gary Cohen informs us that Jerry has said he was trying to stay away from Takahashi, so once again he is going back on his word. When Pelf proceeds to intentionally pitch around Chipper Jones to get to the back-to-back lefties in Brian McCann and Eric Hinske, one would assume Takahashi was warming up for the lefty-on-lefty matchup. But instead, Jerry decides to keep Pelfrey in, making the decision to warm up Takahshi in the first place baffling. Of course, McCann proceeds to rip a double into right field, then after an intentional walk to Hinske to load the bases, Pelfrey hits the next batter to force in a run.
First of all, the fact that Takahashi wasn’t brought in for the lefty-on-lefty matchup tells me that the only reason he was warming up was in case Pelfrey fell apart. If that’s the case then that just goes to show you how much confidence Jerry Manuel has in this team to begin with. But in any event, was it really necessary for Takahashi to be the one brought in? If he’s overworked and needs a rest then give him a rest! Why not use Raul Valdes, a lefty whose prime job all year has been as a long reliever/lefty specialist? I’m dying to hear why that move would have made less sense than bringing in a guy who you admitted yourself was overworked and needed a day or two off.
Nobody expects Jerry Manuel to return next year anyway, so why wait until the end of the season to get rid of him? Fire him now, hire Bob Melvin on an interim basis and see what he can do. After the season, get rid of the entire coaching staff, line up some managerial interviews — Melvin, Backman, Valentine, etc. – and let whoever you hire assemble their own staff. I would also give Omar Minaya the ax, which I believe is long overdue. He’s the one who created this roster, which everyone thought was not very well constructed. He was the one who gave terrible contracts to Oliver Perez, Luis Castillo and Alex Cora. He needs to take the majority of the blame. Who would replace him? In reality it would probably be Wayne Krivsky, the former Reds GM who is now a special assistant with the Mets. But I would love to see the Mets at least try to make a run at Josh Byrnes, the former Arizona Diamondbacks GM who was just inexplicably recently let go. Either way, something needs to be done.
Ben Franklin defined insanity as doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. The Mets collapsed in 2007, did the same in 2008, didn’t even come close in 2009, and are now out of it with two months left this season. Omar has been there for all of it, and Jerry is responsible for the past three seasons as the manager. A change is not a suggestion, it is a necessity. Not only are the Mets acting insane, but they’re driving their fans insane as well.